As Elections Near, War for Allies Heats Up


The war between UPA (led by Congress) and NDA (led by BJP) is heating up as D-day approaches. With most opinion polls showing the favourite NDA falling short of majority, NDA is desperately looking for new allies. Congress on the other hand is wooing allies to spoil the chances of BJP. Others excluding Left Front are expected to get 170-180 seats (1/3rd of Lok Sabha strength). So every seat counts!

Regional parties like Shiv Sena and Akali Dal have been with NDA for long. Congress is currently left with Pawar’s NCP, National Conference (NC)., Soren’s JMM and RLD.

India has seen coalition govts. since 1990s under PV Narasimha Rao (1991-1996), under Deve Gowda & IK Gujral (1996-98), under AB Vajpayee (1998-2004) and under Manmohan Singh (2004-current). Smaller / bigger regional parties have supported govts. at the center in turn for ministerial berths and packages for their states. Most of these regional parties don’t have any ideology and go with whichever formation is in a position to form govt. at the center.

Many parties which were there in NDA govt. from 1999-2004 shifted sides after it lost elections and UPA formed govt. Notable among them were DMK, Rashtriya Lok Dal, Jharkhand Mukti Morcha, Paswan’s Lok Janshakti Party, National Conference, Trinamool Congress etc.

The two mainstream parties have limited presence in many states or are weaker in many states necessitating the need for alliances. These states are Andhra Pradesh (42), Tamil Nadu (39), Uttar Pradesh (80), Bihar (40), Orissa (21), Jammu & Kasmir (6), Jharkhand (14), West Bengal (42), Haryana (10), Punjab 14), Maharashtra (48) due to historical reasons or recent events. While alliances in Maharashtra and Punjab have been firmed up by both BJP & Congress, others states are more or less still open. On a daily basis now there is news of this party in discussions with that party, this party not happy in existing coalition, this party being poached by rival coalition etc. The war will heat up. Exciting!

We take a look at the states where alliances have not yet been finalized and the key regional parties which are being wooed by BJP & Congress. Very difficult to predict where will they finally go or go alone.

Seemandhra: There are two key regional parties here – YSR Congress led by Jagan Reddy and Telugu Desam Party led by Chandrababu Naidu. Both are principally opposed to creation of Telangana, though in 2009 TDP had an electoral alliance with Telangana  Rashtriya Samiti (TRS) which is an advocator of separate state. Basically TDP posturing because of hard stance taken by Jagan. BJP is wooing TDP for some time, problem is BJP supports Telangana while TDP opposes. This could impact vote share of BJP in Telangana. YSR virtually gave an offer to support Modi if he supports united Andhra. With BJP supporting Telangana, this option is mostly closed. YSR could have back channel negotiations with Congress in a deal for state Chief Ministership with his arch rival Kiran Reddy now out of Congress.

Telangana: In this to be created state, BJP and Congress both are wooing K. Chandrasekhar Rao’s TRS. Rao had earlier stated that he would merge his party with Congress if Sonia created Telangana. Now his wish coming true, Congress is pressurizing TRS to merge. Rao is a wily character and very unpredictable. All depends on who gives him a better deal.

Tamil Nadu: This state is dominated by Karunanidhi’s DMK and Jayalalitha’s AIADMK. There are host of other smaller Dravidian parties like Vijaykanth’s DMDK, Vaiko’s MDMK, PMK etc. Karuna’s party DMK was in UPA govt. from 2004 till very recently when it withdrew support to govt., ostensibly unhappy over UPA’s defense of its minister A. Raja and daughter Kanimozhi in 2G scam. The real reason is that astute politician he is, he can see the writing on the wall and doesn’t want to be swamped away by anti-incumbency wave against Congress. He did praise Modi once but BJP was busy wooing Jaya. Now with Jaya in Third Front and throwing her hat in the ring for Prime Ministership, BJP might look at DMK. It has already tied up with MDMK and PMK. DMK & DMDK both being wooed by Congress & BJP.

Uttar Pradesh: This has two big state parties Samajwadi Party and Bahujan Samaj Party. Both of them provide outside support to Congress. Mulayam’s SP is in govt. in the state. Mulayam has already joined Third Front. So it leaves Mayawati’s BSP. Congress is wooing her desperately but she has so far resisted. Problem with BSP is that while their votes transfer to alliance partner, alliance partner’s votes don’t get transferred to them. They have earlier formed govt. in the state with BJP and also had an alliance with Congress. Will definitely improve the chances of whoever aligns with her.

Bihar: Bihar has a peculiar situation with Nitish’s party JDU breaking ties with BJP. Other regional players like Lalu and Paswan are also powerful. Here the situation is exactly the opposite of what is there in other states. Nitish & Lalu both have been wooing Congress for some time. Congress is as confused as ever. Paswan earlier part of RJD-Congress-LJP alliance was unhappy with seat sharing, complained to Sonia & urged her to form alliance with JDU. JDU also parallely wooing Paswan. When Congress firmed up its alliance with Lalu, it was expected that Paswan would join JDU alliance. But he stayed away. Now comes another surprise. When it seemed that alliances have been finalized, Paswan announces he is joining BJP alliance. Position still not clear. JDU / Lalu can’t join BJP and BJP-Congress cant join each other. All other permutations and combinations possible.

Jharkhand: There are two key parties here Jharkhand Mukti Morcha and Jharkhand Vikas Morcha. Shibu Soren is currently in state govt with his son as Chief Minsiter supported by Congress. But he could change group before election as his govt. could still survive with BJP support. Babulal Marandi is an old time BJP member forced to form his won party. He might go with BJP / Congress depending upon circumstances.

West Bengal: This is much simpler. Mamata Banerjee of Trinamool Congress has ditched Congress recently and can’t align with Left her principal opposition party in state. She would either go with BJP or fight alone. BJP is wooing her though….

Orissa: Similar to W. Bengal. Biju Janata Dal can’t go with Congress its principal opposition party in the state. It joined Third Front but abstained from the last meeting. It could either align with BJP its erstwhile partner (till 2009) or go alone.

Haryana: Principal parties here are Om Prakash Chautala’s Indian National Lok Dal and Kuldeep Vishnoi’s NLD and HVC. BJP is wooing both of them. Let see what happens. Both of them have been with NDA earlier.

As elections near, most of them barring bigger ones like Maya / Mamata could go the BJP way in anticipation of some ministerial berths as all polls show them leading the pack. Back channel negotiations have already begun with most of them for seat arrangements. BJP has to be wary of opportunists as it could dent its anti-corruption plank on which it is attacking Congress. A lot of these leaders have a corrupt background. Lene ke dene na pad jaayen! Lets see what happens….

Lok Sabha 2014: Who will form the next govt.?


We have completed the All India Projections including detailed projections for BJP / NDA, Congress / UPA and Aam Aadmi Party.

Lok Sabha 2014 elections is expected to throw a hung house with BJP led NDA leading the pack with 220 seats, followed by Congress led UPA at 100 seats. Others (including Left & regional parties) are expected to bag 220 seats as per Politicalbaaba projections. They will hold the keys to govt. formation at the center.

We have also seen which regional parties would support UPA & NDA post polls under the post named “What will be the strategy of regional parties post polls?”.

So the million dollar question is who will form the govt. in May 2014?

I. BJP led NDA (probability 80%)

NDA under Modi is expected to bag 220 seats. Including Telugu Desam Party with which it is expected to have a pre-poll alliance, NDA would reach 230.  40+ short of majority. Being the single largest formation President of India will invite Modi to form govt. Creation of Third Front and AIADMK / Biju Janata Dal / Assam Gana Parishad joining it makes it a bit tricky for Modi. These parties were expected to join NDA but now with them in Third Front possibility low.

Parties like Mulayam (14), Lalu / Paswan (12), Left Front (31), AIADMK (27), Naveen Patnaik (15) would not support Modi (high probability).  Mayawati could also decide not to support because this time main fight in Uttar Pradesh is between BJP and BSP. Kejri Baba (11) would also not support BJP. Jealousy of current Chief Ministers like Jayalalitha, Naveen Patnaik, Nitish Kumar with Modi would stop them from supporting Modi.

Mamata could bail out NDA, BJP is not the principal opposition party in W.Bengal, so she has no threat and she was earlier part of NDA. Since AIADMK is in Third Front, BJP could take support of DMK. This along with other smaller parties would help NDA touch the magical figure. The govt. though could be unstable. Mamata Di’s support is crucial for NDA govt. formation at the center. Without her it will be difficult to form govt.

Additionally Jagan Mohan Reddy (14) and Telangana Rashtriya Samiti (8) could provide outside support as they will refrain from joining govt. as TDP (their opponent) is in the govt. Assumption TRS doesn’t merge with Congress before polls.

Current UPA allies like Pawar’s NCP, Shibu Soren’s JMM and Ajit Singh’s RLD could also turn out to be potential allies and they can rock UPA’s boat to join NDA (10 seats). JMM’s govt. is dependent upon Congress in Jharkhand, even if Congress withdraws support BJP would come in and ensure that it runs smoothly. This takes up the overall tally to 307 seats.

NDA (BJP + S. Sena + Akali Dal + MDMK) 220
Telugu Desam Party 10
Trinamool Congress (High Dependence) 25
Maharashtra Navnirman Sena 3
Indian National Lok Dal 2
DMK 6
Others / Independents 9
Total 275
Outside Support  
YSR Congress 14
Telangana Rashtriya Samiti 8
Nationalist Congress Party 6
Jharkhand Mukti Morcha 3
Rashtriya Lok Dal 1
Total 307
 

2. Third Front (probability 10%)

UPA is expected to bag 100 seats, even if you add Lalu its tally goes up to 112 and will not be in a position to form govt. It won’t want to form govt. as well. But to stop Modi at any cost it will try to prop together a Third Front govt.

With Third Front expected to bag 100 seats, there will still be a gap of 60 seats. This govt. can’t be formed with Mamata and / or Mayawati’s support. Mayawati would ensure Mulayam and Jaya won’t become PM (ladies rivalry). Maya could provide outside support.  Mamata won’t join as her principal opponent Left Front is already in. So PM could be a consensus candidate either from Left Front or AIADMK.

1996 like experiment with Gowda / Gujral as PM. This will be a khichdi govt. , highly unstable. Congress would provide outside support and will act as the glue which will hold this coalition together till it wants. Won’t last long though, however, hard they try.

Parties like Shiv Sena, Akali Dal, TDP and DMK won’t join this alliance at any cost. It is noted that this formation will get opportunity only after BJP is unable to prove majority in Lok Sabha.

Left Front 31
AIADMK 27
Biju Janata Dal 15
Samajwadi Party 14
Janata Dal Secular 1
Janata Dal United 10
Assam Gana Parishad 2
Third Front 100
Rashtriya Janata Dal 12
Indian National Lok Dal 2
Maharashta Navnirman Sena 3
Bahujan Samaj Party 20
Aam Aadmi Party 11
YSR Congress 14
Telangana Rashtriya Samiti 8
Others / Independents 20
Nationalist Congress Party 6
Jharkhand Mukti Morcha 3
Rashtriya Lok Dal 1
Total 200
Outside Support
Congress 90
Total 290

 3. Re-elections (10% probability)

If BJP is unable to prove majority (principal reason could be that Modi’s name is not acceptable to allies) and Left Front can’t be cobbled together (because of its inherent contradictions) then stage will be re-set for re-elections. Similar situation like in 1998 when Vajpayee was unable to prove majority by 1 vote leading to re-elections.

So guys please go out and vote and give a clear mandate. We need a strong govt. to tide over the times currently facing our country and economy.

Related Posts:

https://politicalbaaba.wordpress.com/2014/01/14/2014-lok-sabha-projections-how-many-seats-will-aaam-aaadmi-party-win/

https://politicalbaaba.wordpress.com/2014/01/16/2014-lok-sabha-projections-how-many-seats-will-bjp-win/

https://politicalbaaba.wordpress.com/2014/01/25/2014-lok-sabha-projections-how-many-seats-will-congress-get/

https://politicalbaaba.wordpress.com/2014/01/30/all-india-lok-sabha-projections-2014/

https://politicalbaaba.wordpress.com/2014/02/05/what-will-be-the-strategy-of-regional-parties-post-lok-sabha-polls-2/

Poll

Jayalalitha throws hat in the ring for Prime Ministership


AIADMK’s Jayalalitha has raised her hand up to be counted as a contender for Prime Minister post. So there is competition for Modi and Rahul. She has joined Third Front which consists of 11 parties – CPM, CPI, Forward Bloc, RSP, Assam Gana Parishad, Janata Dal (United), Janata Dal (Secular), Samajwadi Party, AIADMK, Biju Janata Dal (BJD), and Jharkhand Vikas Morcha. Essentially the group is of 8 parties with Left Front a front within the front. These parties together account for 92 Lok Sabha seats currently. As per Politicalbaaba projections they are expected to win ~100 seats. Though, the Front has not formally announced their PM candidate, Left Front which is amongst the largest constituent has promised suppport to Amma for PM. This is a setback of sorts for BJP which expected AIADMK to support it post polls. Though this is still possible and cannot be completely ruled out.

Why Amma agreed to be part of Third Front which is full of tall egoist leaders like Mulayam, Nitish, Deve Gowda and faces a lot of internal contradictions?

Jaya is a smart politician. She knows the limitations / contradictions of Left Front and the fact that some leaders are not reliable. Mulayam, Nitish, Gowda would never allow her to be PM as they all themselves have PM ambitions. So why did she agree to be part of this Front and rub BJP (which is likely to form govt. as per majority of surveys) the wrong way before polls. After all it is in the interest of state parties to have cordial relations with the Center. Plus Amma is perceived as a friend of Modi, they both attend each other’s swearing in ceremonies.

Amma the shrewd politician she is, knows fully well that AIADMK is going to be the largest party of the Third Front along with Left parties. Left parties would not be interested in govt. formation like in 1996. Plus they are backing her. Mulayam, Nitish, Deve Gowda all are expected to register decline in seats, so they would not be as powerful as they are currently (in terms of no. of seats). Naveen too wouldn’t like to head a khicdi govt. So she would emerge as the undisputed leader of the Front. If Mulayam / Nitish fume they would not get ministries.

So she has taken a punt. She has nothing to lose.

Possibilities for Amma

Punt that BJP / NDA would not get majority on their own. Even surveys predict that NDA could be 50 seats short of majority, so others (excluding BJP) would get 320 seats. In that situation all anti Modi / anti BJP parties could be brought under one umbrella by Congress is what she anticipates. Third Front could form govt. with support of Congress and Others and she could emerge as PM. Here she is assuming that Maya and Mamata will fall in line as they would get less seats than AIADMK and Congress would take lead to bring them to fold.

If this doesn’t happen, she doesn’t lose anything. She remains CM of Tamil Nadu. At the max BJP / NDA govt. would not take her in and some of her MPs would not become Cabinet Ministers. So what! This is her party. Dreams of other members have been sacrificed by dream of their supreme leader.

As regards cordial relationship with Center, she has been anti-Congress and has been running state govt. with a showdown with the center. So she doesn’t care. Infact she would try to gain sympathy by saying that central govt. is anti T. Nadu.

She has dreams to become PM. She feels it is her best chance. So she is giving it her best shot…….

Third Front being formed, God save India!


After being snubbed by Congress, Nitish is now leading efforts to cobble together a Third Front. He has called upon  leaders of the erstwhile “Janata Party / Parivaar” to come together to take on the Congress and the BJP. Janata Party formed govt. in 1977 with Bhartiya Lok Dal and Bhartiya Jan Sangh (now BJP) as its alliance partners. People voted against Indira’s emergency measures. The govt. couldn’t last its full term due to internal conflicts and Indira came back to power in 1980.

Janata Party disintegrated into a number of smaller parties as their tall leaders fell apart due to their big egos. Janata Party became Janata Dal and Janata Dal further split into JD(A to Z). Regional satraps Mulayam Singh Yadav (Samajwadi Party), Ajit Singh (Rashtriya Lok Dal), Nitish Kumar (Janata Dal United), Naveen Patnaik (Biju Janata Dal), Deve Gowda (Janata Dal Secular), Lalu Yadav (Rashtriya Janata Dal) were all part of the Janata Parivaar earlier. Some of the above like Ajit and Lalu are with Congress now.

Nitish is in talks with Mulayam and Naveen to form a grand alliance. He is also trying to rope in Left Front and AIADMK and talking of a 10 party alliance. These parties together have ~90 seats currently. While SP and JDU seats will decline, this will be made up by higher seats of Left / AIADMK. So roughly they could get same no. of seats and will depend on Congress / other parties to provide outside support. Pawar, Asom Gana Parishad etc. could also join after polls.

The Front continues to suffer from internal contradictions and shortcomings. Two big anti-Congress / anti-BJP parties Bahujan Samaj Party and Trinamool Congress won’t join the alliance at any cost. Maya since Mulayam is there and Mamata since Left is there. Plus DMK also won’t join assuming AIADMK is there. From Andhra only one of Jagan or Naidu could join at the best.

So all in all this Third Front would not pose any real threat to Congress or BJP. Jayalalitha could agree to be part of this alliance as she knows that her party would bag the highest no. of seats and in case of fractured mandate (like Delhi), Congress would chose to support her as Prime Minister to keep Modi at bay. Not easy, but a remote possibility.

The best part of this alliance if it fructifies is that every body (except for Left) wants to be PM and won’t let the other become PM. Would Nitish allow Mulayam / Gowda to be PM or vice-a-versa? Never! Nitish is behaving like a khisiani bill and wants to teach Congress / BJP a lesson.

However, this does help Congress. Congress Plan A – Aam Aadmi Party is fizzling out, so this could act as Plan B to stop BJP juggernaut. Most probably this Front will die before it is even born. Ek mayan mein itni talwarein kaise rahengi! Only time will tell.

For parties like AIADMK, BJD this is also a bit tricky situation as they are possible alliance partners of NDA / BJP post polls. If they join Third Front it will be difficult for them to leave sinking ship and jump onto to BJP ship post polls. Difficult but not impossible. Anything for power!

India doesn’t want a 1996 like situation where Deve Gowda and Gujral of Janata Dal (with only 46 seats) became PM supported by Left (44 seats), Congress (140 seats) and other parties. God save us from this Third Front full of jokers!

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑